The headline from a Broncos fan site yesterday—”No-brainer AJ Brown-Broncos trade is too good for Eagles to refuse”—has sparked a lot of debate, and you’re right, it does make some sense on the surface. A proposed deal sending A.J. Brown to Denver for a 2026 second-round pick and fifth-rounder feels like a steal for the Broncos… but is it really too good for Philly to pass up? Let’s dive into why this rumor has legs, but also why it’s far from a slam dunk.
Why the Rumor Exists: Frustration in Philly
A.J. Brown, at 28, remains one of the NFL’s elite wideouts—physical, explosive after the catch, and a proven 1,000-yard threat when heavily involved. But in 2025, his production has dipped (around 935 yards through mid-season in some reports), largely due to the Eagles’ run-heavy scheme under Nick Sirianni and Kellen Moore. Philly ranks near the bottom in passing attempts, leaning on Saquon Barkley and the tush push.
Brown has voiced frustration multiple times this season—cryptic social media posts, post-game comments about usage, and even a reported meeting with ownership. ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler recently noted that “several executives” believe the Eagles could move him this offseason, citing the taxing locker room dynamic and Brown’s desire for a more pass-oriented offense. He’s under contract through 2029 with about $50M owed over the next two years—manageable for a contender, but Philly would take a cap hit (up to $20M pre-June 1).
The Eagles are defending Super Bowl champs with a stacked roster (DeVonta Smith, Dallas Goedert, Barkley), so trading Brown could free up resources while doubling down on their identity. Howie Roseman loves deals, and if Brown’s unhappiness lingers, a fresh start might benefit everyone.
Why Denver Makes Sense as a Landing Spot
The Broncos are contenders in 2025 behind rookie sensation Bo Nix, a strong defense, and a solid run game. But their passing attack needs a true alpha—Courtland Sutton is reliable, but the depth chart (Troy Franklin, Marvin Mims, Pat Bryant) lacks a dominant X receiver like Brown.
Sean Payton has long admired Brown’s skill set (he praised him back in 2019), and pairing him with Sutton would give Nix a nightmare duo. Denver has cap space projected for 2026, extra draft picks, and motivation to go all-in while Nix is on his rookie deal. A second + fifth feels light for Brown (similar to what Philly paid for him in 2022: a first and third), but if the Eagles prioritize resetting the WR dynamic, it could appeal.
Why It’s Not a “No-Brainer” for the Eagles
Championship contenders rarely trade away Pro Bowl talents in their prime. Brown and DeVonta Smith form one of the league’s best duos—trading him creates a massive hole opposite Smith, forcing reliance on Jahan Dotson or free agents/draft picks. Philly’s pass game struggles stem more from play-calling and Jalen Hurts’ conservatism than Brown himself.
Roseman has shut down in-season trade talk before, and post-Super Bowl, the focus is repeating, not rebuilding the skill group. A lowball offer like a 2026 second might get laughed off—execs peg Brown’s value closer to multiple firsts or a high pick + player (earlier mocks had Marvin Mims + a third).
If Brown welcomes a change (as Fowler suggests), Philly might listen, but they’d demand an overpay. This feels more like Broncos wishful thinking than an irresistible deal.
Bottom Line: Intriguing, But Unlikely Soon
Yeah, it makes sense on paper—Brown gets more targets in Payton’s scheme, Denver gets a superstar, Philly gets picks to reload. But for the Eagles, ditching a 28-year-old All-Pro after a title feels premature unless the frustration boils over.
This is offseason fodder for now—no imminent move with the season ongoing. If Philly flames out in playoffs, though? All bets off. Broncos fans can dream, but Eagles hold the cards.
Leave a Reply