Andrew Nembhard Shines with 19 Points in Heartbreaking Loss to Magic

In a tightly contested New Year’s Eve battle at Gainbridge Fieldhouse on December 31, 2025, Indiana Pacers guard Andrew Nembhard delivered another strong performance, finishing with 19 points on efficient 9-of-15 shooting (including 1-of-5 from three-point range), four rebounds, seven assists, and one steal across 31 minutes. Despite his efforts, the Pacers fell 112-110 to the visiting Orlando Magic on Paolo Banchero’s clutch layup with 7.5 seconds left, extending Indiana’s losing streak to 10 games and dropping their record to a league-worst 6-28.

Nembhard’s outing exemplified his growing role as a two-way force for the Pacers amid a tumultuous season. The fourth-year guard has stepped into a larger responsibility following Tyrese Haliburton’s season-ending Achilles injury, handling primary ball-handling duties with poise and efficiency. Over his last 12 games, Nembhard has reached double-digit scoring in 10 contests and recorded at least one steal in eight, averaging 16.9 points, 7.3 assists, 2.8 rebounds, 1.7 three-pointers, and 1.2 steals per game. His play has been one of the few consistent positives for Indiana during this prolonged skid.

The game against Orlando featured intense back-and-forth action, with Nembhard contributing key plays on both ends. His seven assists helped facilitate movement against the Magic’s stout defense, while his steal and defensive activity disrupted Orlando’s rhythm at times. Shooting 60% from the field, Nembhard attacked the paint effectively, drawing fouls and creating opportunities for teammates like Pascal Siakam and Bennedict Mathurin.

Born on January 16, 2000, in Aurora, Ontario, Canada, Andrew William Nembhard’s basketball roots run deep. His older brother, Ryan Nembhard, also pursued the sport at a high level. Andrew honed his skills at Vaughan Secondary School and Montverde Academy in Florida, emerging as a top recruit. He committed to the University of Florida initially but transferred to Gonzaga University, where he became a standout point guard under coach Mark Few.

At Gonzaga, Nembhard earned West Coast Conference All-Freshman honors in 2018-19 and helped lead the Bulldogs to deep NCAA Tournament runs. Known for his high basketball IQ, calm demeanor, and elite passing, he averaged over 9 points and 5 assists in his sophomore year before declaring for the 2022 NBA Draft. Selected 31st overall by the Indiana Pacers, Nembhard quickly made an impact as a rookie.

His breakout moment came early: on November 28, 2022, as a rookie, Nembhard hit a buzzer-beating three-pointer to stun the Los Angeles Lakers 116-115, announcing his arrival on the national stage. That shot remains one of the most memorable in recent Pacers history.

Over his first three seasons, Nembhard developed into a reliable backup and occasional starter, showcasing defensive versatility and low-turnover playmaking. His sophomore year saw improved scoring, and in 2024-25, he played a crucial role in Indiana’s surprising Finals run. With Haliburton orchestrating, Nembhard provided steady complementary play, earning praise for his clutch performances in the playoffs.

Entering 2025-26, expectations were high for the Haliburton-Nembhard backcourt duo. Tragedy struck early, however, with Haliburton’s injury derailing the season. Nembhard, thrust into the starting point guard role full-time, has responded admirably. His recent stretch—highlighted by the 19-point effort against Orlando—demonstrates growth in scoring aggression while maintaining elite facilitation (low turnover rate) and defense.

Statistically, Nembhard’s impact extends beyond the box score. He ranks among the league’s better guards in defensive rating when on the floor, using his 6-foot-4 frame and quick hands to disrupt opponents. His assist-to-turnover ratio remains strong, a hallmark of his game since college.

Coach Rick Carlisle has lauded Nembhard’s maturity: “He’s been our steady hand through all this. The way he competes on both ends, night in and night out, is exactly what we need.” Teammates echo this, with Siakam noting Nembhard’s leadership in huddles during tough stretches.

As the Pacers navigate this difficult campaign—focusing on development and lottery positioning—Nembhard’s emergence offers hope. At 25, he’s locked into a team-friendly extension signed in 2024, positioning him as a core piece alongside young talents like Mathurin and Jarace Walker.

Looking ahead, Indiana hosts the Magic again on January 1, 2026, seeking revenge and a streak-snapping win. Nembhard’s consistent production will be vital against Orlando’s length and athleticism.

Off the court, Nembhard represents Canada internationally and engages in community work, reflecting his grounded personality. His journey from Canadian prospect to NBA starter inspires, embodying quiet excellence.

In losses like the one to Orlando, Nembhard’s 19 points, seven assists, and all-around play remind fans why he’s a foundational building block. As Indiana rebuilds, Andrew Nembhard’s steady rise provides reason for optimism in 2026 and beyond.